“Ebenezer” is a fun, ghoulish addition to the many cinematic adaptations to Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol. Directed by Ti West, known for horror movies, “Ebenezer” is rated PG-13 for frightening material. The depiction of the three main spirits and other ghosts can be unsettling and the cause of nightmares, but the sentiment, Johhny Depp-style comedic relief, and handling of the story’s resolution counterbalances the story well.
Given the spooky-centric lens, “Ebenezer” showcases Scrooge’s restlessness throughout his encounters with the past, present, and future as well as the stark reality of what it means to face your inevitable death.
The restless heart
Johnny Depp’s flavor of an oddball performance brought forth a sense of restlessness present in Scrooge that brought to mind a quote from St. Augustine’s Confessions, where he wrote, “For you made us for yourself, and our hearts are restless until they find their rest in you” (Book 1, Chapter 1).
In many ways, Scrooge’s journey to redemption mirrors St. Augustine’s. Both spent most of their lives pursuing worldly wealth and neglecting God. Scrooge only wants to accumulate wealth and not use it for any creature comforts, embodying, “For the love of money is the root of all evils, and some people in their desire for it have strayed from the faith and have pierced themselves with many pains” (1 Timothy 6:10).
RELATED | ‘You Can See Everything’ review: But what are they showing you?
Neither St. Augustine or Scrooge turned their lives around until their worldviews were shaken to the core and they became aware of the pains they have been causing themselves and others. For St. Augustine, it started by encountering the masterful preaching of St. Ambrose. For Scrooge, it begins with the horrific visit of Jacob Marley (Ian McKellan) and the three ghosts of Christmas past, present, and future.
Both figures have intercessors on their journeys. St. Augustine’s mother, St. Monica, prayed, fasted and wept for his conversion while he lived out his wayward lifestyle. Scrooge’s nephew, Fred (Sam Claflin), vows to always invite his uncle over to his house in hopes for the goodness that once was alive in Scrooge’s deceased sister (Fred’s mother) might come alive in Scrooge.
Both prodigals are faced with the impact of their life’s decisions and choose to change. By facing the darkness that has come to light, they enter the restless journey to the true promise of Christmas.
Memento mori
One might think it’s weird that “Ebenezer” was released in mid-November. After viewing the movie, I came to appreciate its greater connection of what November is to the Catholic faith. In Catholicism, November is the month dedicated to the Holy Souls in Purgatory. It is a time to pray for those who have died in God’s grace and friendship but are still imperfectly purified and need to undergo purification to enter the joy of Heaven (Catechism of the Catholic Church 1030).
The practice of praying for the dead has a scriptural basis in 2 Maccabees 12:46, “Thus [Judas Maccabeus] made atonement for the dead that they might be absolved from their sin.”
A Christmas Carol and “Ebenezer” are works of fiction, but they certainly involve encounters with suffering spirits. “Ebenezer” elevates the spirit-aspect of the story to where Scrooge is chased by a horde of spirits whenever he tries to veer off the path of the main spirits he is supposed to follow.
The Ghost of Christmas Present (Tramell Tillman) is less jolly than traditionally depicted and more of a reflection of the harsh present Scrooge is creating for himself and those around him in Victorian London. The spirits of Ignorance (Samuel Kolonko) and Want (Mia Tormey) under the Ghost of Christmas Present’s cloak provide frights too unnerving to spoil here. This more culturally Halloween take of the classic tale unknowingly links it closer to All Soul’s Day (November 2nd), the end of Hallowtide and the central day of the Month of the Holy Souls in Purgatory.
November is also the end of the liturgical year, where the Sunday Gospel readings focus on death, the Final Judgement, Hell, and Heaven. The emphasis is not to merely be fire and brimstone or doom and gloom, but a reminder that earthly death is inevitable and eternal life in Heaven is possible through Christ.
RELATED | ‘Jimmy’ review: Is it a wonderful life?
“Memento mori” is a Latin phrase that means “remember to die” or “remember that you will die.” With roots in antiquity, memento mori can be found throughout Christian burial sites, artwork, and architecture. “Ebenezer” capitalizes on this concept, as its source material is one big memento mori.
Memento mori symbolism is prevalent throughout “Ebenezer,” reminiscent of the Catholic Church’s use of similar symbolism. This includes Scrooge being followed by a black crow, flames in lamp posts extinguishing on their own, and Scrooge in the crypt of a church aligned with skulls and bones as he meets the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come (Robert Strange).
While we, like Scrooge, will face death, we also face Christmas Day. Whether or not we choose to fully participate in the meaning of Christmas is up to us. Fortunately for Scrooge, he and all around him benefit from him saying “yes” to the hope of Christmas.
Final thoughts
Through in the use of well-thought-out symbolism, scenes taking place in a church and the church’s crypt, “Ebenezer” might be the closest movie to a Catholic gothic-style genre in recent cinema.
It did feel a little long at times and the CGI used on the ghosts chasing Scrooge was a bit off the rest of the movie’s aesthetic, but “Ebenezer” captures the spirit of what makes A Christmas Carol and its many adaptations timeless. “Ebenezer” also separates itself from other adaptations by including a backstory with Jacob Marley and more fleshed out archs/resolutions with Fred, Belle (Ellie Bamber and Sara Galvin), and Scrooge’s sister (Rose Williams).
The resolution with Bob Cratchit (Rupert Grint) is slightly different but plays out differently in a way still keeping with the spirit of the book. Bob’s backstory is expanded to show him and Tiny Tim (Freddie Lee-Grey) attending a church service.
Johnny Depp was the perfect Scrooge for this adaptation because his overall spontaneity and reactions to the spookiness surrounding him give the audience a great window into Scrooge’s psyche and much needed relief.
Although I might stick with watching “The Muppet Christmas Carol” (1992) with my children during the Advent and Christmas seasons, “Ebenezer” is a contender for watching before or during Advent with my wife to help us remember our own mortality and enter into the mindset of what Christmas is really about: the birth of our Savior.
